the-roots-of-hindu-nationalism-in-india
Can a society overcome deeply entrenched religious and caste divisions to embrace a more rational and egalitarian future?
Four Murdered Critics of Hindu Nationalism examines how hindu nationalism threatens rationalism in India, following a long and uneasy contest between faith and reason shaped by caste hierarchy and political power. Moving chronologically, the film connects today’s climate of intimidation to earlier moments when scientific thought and reformist politics began challenging religious dogma, and when leaders debated what a modern, egalitarian nation should look like. Through an urgent, reflective documentary approach, it asks whether India can build a future grounded in scientific temper and equal rights.
Anchored by the work of rationalist Dr. Narendra Dabholkar, the narrative shows how campaigns against superstition become flashpoints in communities where belief, identity, and social rank are deeply entangled. The story widens to include pivotal historical shifts, from the formation of the Indian National Congress to the assassination of Gandhi, and to the contrasting visions of justice and social transformation associated with figures like Ambedkar. Against this backdrop, the caste system emerges not as a relic but as a continuing barrier to dignity and unity, intensifying the stakes of any movement that seeks change.
Interviews and testimonies place contemporary tensions alongside historical analysis, emphasizing how religious extremism can turn debate into danger. The film’s climax arrives with the violent assassinations of rationalist voices—among them Dabholkar and Pansare—presented as a brutal symbol of what is at risk when dissent is silenced. Without claiming easy resolution, the documentary closes as a call to collective action: to continue the unfinished work of those who argued that progress depends on questioning, evidence, and solidarity across divides, especially as hindu nationalism reshapes public life. Watch to confront the questions it raises and decide what kind of future reason can still win.
From late colonial rule through post-independence India, mass politics grew alongside debates over secularism, caste equality, and religious identity. Partition, recurring communal violence, and the rise of Hindu nationalist movements sharpened pressure on dissent, reform, and scientific temper.
Knowledge Quiz
Test Your Knowledge
Pick an answer to see whether you got it right — and why.
1 / 8
0 correct so far
This film’s dominant mode is expository. It builds a clear, chronological case through interviews, testimony, and historical context, guiding viewers toward a firm argument. This approach delivers its viewpoint by directly challenging superstition and caste hierarchy, framing rationalism and social justice as urgent, necessary choices.
Director & Year: Anand Patwardhan, 2018.
Rationalist Leader: Dr. Narendra Dabholkar (1 November 1945–20 August 2013) was a Maharashtra-based physician and rationalist who campaigned against superstition and was assassinated in Pune on 20 August 2013. Wikipedia
Left Activist: Govind Pansare (1933–20 February 2015) was a Communist Party of India leader and author who was shot by assailants in Kolhapur on 16 February 2015 and died from his injuries on 20 February 2015. Wikipedia
Anti-Caste Icon: B. R. Ambedkar (1891–1956) chaired the Constituent Assembly’s Drafting Committee established on 29 August 1947, a central role in framing India’s Constitution adopted on 26 November 1949. Yojana (Publications Division, Govt. of India)
Independence-Era Flashpoint: Mahatma Gandhi was assassinated in New Delhi on 30 January 1948 by Nathuram Godse, a pivotal event often referenced in accounts of post-independence political violence. Wikipedia
Backstory Trigger: A wave of killings of public anti-superstition voices in India, beginning with Dabholkar’s murder in 2013 and followed by Pansare’s in 2015, helped catalyze renewed focus on threats faced by rationalist and dissenting movements. Polish Film Festival (Gdynia) article
Hindu Nationalist Context: The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), founded in Nagpur in 1925 by K. B. Hedgewar, is a major Hindu nationalist organization frequently cited in discussions of India’s contemporary right-wing political ecosystem. RSS (official FAQ)
Political Timeframe: Accounts of contemporary communal and caste-related tensions in India are commonly situated in the period after Narendra Modi’s national government took office in 2014, amid debates over secularism, dissent, and majoritarian politics. Scroll.in
Topical context
This film is part of the World Map of Conflict dataset—an interactive documentary collection that combines curated films with conflict data and country context to explain geopolitical developments since 1945.
Within the collection, the film sits in the Tradition and Religion educational pathway, which examines tensions that arise when globalist forces collide with currents of traditionalism.
Within that pathway, the film falls under the subtopic The Rise of Hindu Nationalism. It explores how Hindutva grew from the Hindu Mahasabha and the RSS of the colonial era into a political force that now shapes India’s government, citizenship and secularism.
The film shows the cost of opposing that rise. Four rationalists who fought superstition and caste are shot dead: Narendra Dabholkar, Govind Pansare, M.M. Kalburgi and Gauri Lankesh. Their families and fellow activists point to Hindu nationalist groups. The film sets these killings beside lynchings of Muslims and Dalits, and traces the ideas behind them back to Savarkar and the assassination of Gandhi.
Learning Throughlines
Rationalism versus religious dogma as a driver of mobilisation and conflict.
The film opens with the constitutional duty of every Indian citizen to promote scientific temper, then follows Narendra Dabholkar’s anti-superstition committee as it re-creates godmen’s tricks, from a wire through the tongue to a chain conjured out of the air, under the rule that anyone who performs such miracles is a scoundrel, whoever believes him a fool and whoever does not oppose him a coward. After his murder, crowds answer the question of who will complete his unfinished work with a chant of “We will!” The conflict reaches everyday ritual too: rationalists urge clay Ganesh idols instead of plaster of Paris, while a Sanatan Sanstha appeal calls such opponents anti-religious apostates. Anyone who performs such miracles is a scoundrel 00:08:17
Caste as a structural barrier to equality, from Gandhi and Ambedkar to today.
The narration says Gandhi’s campaign against untouchability, including cleaning latrines himself, and the 1932 Poona Pact with Ambedkar, which first secured reservations for Dalits, made orthodox upper castes furious. In the present, Govind Pansare runs a support centre for inter-caste and inter-religious marriages in Kolhapur, Dalits at a rally in Gujarat vow never again to clean gutters or dispose of animal carcasses, and the film follows Rohith Vemula, a Dalit PhD scholar whose group, a fellow student says, was socially boycotted by a new vice chancellor before Rohith took his own life. His mother Radhika Vemula and her son then take Ambedkar’s 22 vows and embrace Buddhism, while student speakers invoke Ambedkar’s call for social, not only political, democracy. The 1932 Poona Pact and the upper-caste backlash 00:12:39
How assassinations and intimidation shape public debate and civic courage.
Dabholkar is shot on his morning walk by two assailants on a motorcycle, and a reporter later presses the Kolhapur police on the same pattern in Pansare’s killing, with no arrests three months on; the narration says police suspected Hindu organisations and that Sanatan Sanstha is implicated in the investigations, which a Sanatan supporter dismisses as charges without concrete evidence. Dabholkar’s widow recalls how shouting a slogan with the crowd outside her door gave her a profound sense of fearlessness, even as a man on camera asks why no one broke the director’s bones after a protest. The film closes on journalist Gauri Lankesh, shot dead in Bengaluru by unknown assailants after constant threats, and on crowds chanting that they are all Gauri. Morning walks, two men on a motorcycle, and no arrests 00:17:38
From colonial-era organisation-building to contemporary majoritarian politics.
A brisk prologue runs from the 1857 rebellion and British divide and rule through the founding of the Congress in 1885 to the Muslim League, the Hindu Mahasabha and the RSS, which the narration argues all backed the British during the 1942 Quit India Movement and held that Hindus and Muslims could not coexist in a secular nation. Late in the film, the narration traces Savarkar from mercy petitions in Andaman Jail to the idea of Hindutva and the trial over Gandhi’s assassination, in which it says he was acquitted on technical grounds while his disciples Godse and Apte were hanged. It then shows his revival: a portrait installed in Parliament in 2003, BJP president Amit Shah as chief guest at a Savarkar event, and a Savarkar memorial where visitors learn to shoot. Savarkar's mercy petitions and the idea of Hindutva 01:33:52
Related topics
Documentary Mode
This film’s dominant mode is expository. It builds a clear, chronological case through interviews, testimony, and historical context, guiding viewers toward a firm argument. This approach delivers its viewpoint by directly challenging superstition and caste hierarchy, framing rationalism and social justice as urgent, necessary choices.
Key Facts
Director & Year: Anand Patwardhan, 2018.
Rationalist Leader: Dr. Narendra Dabholkar (1 November 1945–20 August 2013) was a Maharashtra-based physician and rationalist who campaigned against superstition and was assassinated in Pune on 20 August 2013. Wikipedia
Left Activist: Govind Pansare (1933–20 February 2015) was a Communist Party of India leader and author who was shot by assailants in Kolhapur on 16 February 2015 and died from his injuries on 20 February 2015. Wikipedia
Anti-Caste Icon: B. R. Ambedkar (1891–1956) chaired the Constituent Assembly’s Drafting Committee established on 29 August 1947, a central role in framing India’s Constitution adopted on 26 November 1949. Yojana (Publications Division, Govt. of India)
Independence-Era Flashpoint: Mahatma Gandhi was assassinated in New Delhi on 30 January 1948 by Nathuram Godse, a pivotal event often referenced in accounts of post-independence political violence. Wikipedia
Backstory Trigger: A wave of killings of public anti-superstition voices in India, beginning with Dabholkar’s murder in 2013 and followed by Pansare’s in 2015, helped catalyze renewed focus on threats faced by rationalist and dissenting movements. Polish Film Festival (Gdynia) article
Hindu Nationalist Context: The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), founded in Nagpur in 1925 by K. B. Hedgewar, is a major Hindu nationalist organization frequently cited in discussions of India’s contemporary right-wing political ecosystem. RSS (official FAQ)
Political Timeframe: Accounts of contemporary communal and caste-related tensions in India are commonly situated in the period after Narendra Modi’s national government took office in 2014, amid debates over secularism, dissent, and majoritarian politics. Scroll.in















